Why M&A Is a Dream… Until It Isn’t

Thank you to all our subscribers! Share your link to unlock some perks — and don’t miss the surprise at the end! 🫶

Dec 17, 2024

Building your company, dreaming of a legendary exit to a market giant, signing that life-changing deal — only to discover the harsh realities of mergers and acquisitions (M&A). Regret over an unpaid earn-out? Frustration with integration? You wouldn’t be the first.

According to KPMG (2021), a staggering 70% of M&A transactions fail to meet their strategic or financial goals. Yet, M&A persists. Why? Because sometimes, it’s the only way forward. When done right, though, it can become a launchpad for even greater ambitions.

The Relentless Need for an Exit

Venture Capital comes with strings attached. Once you accept VC funding, you enter a game with clear rules: investors expect returns within 7 to 10 years. When the clock runs out, an exit becomes non-negotiable.

The problem? IPOs are rare, accounting for less than 10% of exits and declining steadily in Europe since 2021. Acquisitions dominate, representing over 90% of all exits, according to PitchBook (2022).

Picture this: you’ve raised multiple rounds, expanded into new markets, and built a solid business. But growth starts to plateau, and raising another round becomes tricky. Selling suddenly feels like the logical next step.

But here’s the catch: the sale marks the start of a new chapter, often more challenging than the one before.

From Founder Mode to Manager Mode

The moment you sell, you’re no longer the visionary at the helm. You’re now an employee in a larger corporate machine, with layers of hierarchy, bureaucracy, and processes. This shift — what I call moving from “founder mode” to “manager mode” — is where many founders stumble.

According to Harvard Business Review (2020), 61% of founders leave their roles within two years of an acquisition. Nearly 40% of earn-outs is not paid in full because performance targets are either poorly defined or simply unachievable.

Why? Decisions slow down. Your agile, fast-moving startup gets swallowed by corporate processes. And those “synergies” promised during the deal? They often fail to materialize, especially if they’re not aligned with the acquirer’s internal incentives.

Think of the WhatsApp-Facebook acquisition. The founders left frustrated, citing a loss of vision and mounting cultural clashes.

When Values Clash

Startup culture thrives on innovation, agility, and ambition. Corporate culture, meanwhile, often revolves around optimization, standardization, and predictability. These differences are fertile ground for tension — and founder burnout.

Take Tony Fadell, co-founder of Nest. After selling to Google for $3.2 billion, he described the post-acquisition period as a “constant battle” between Nest’s startup ethos and Alphabet’s bureaucratic priorities.

Earn-outs, the deferred payments tied to hitting post-acquisition performance metrics, only add fuel to the fire. If your priorities as a founder don’t align with those of the acquirer, hitting those targets becomes a near-impossible task.

How to Sell Successfully

M&A isn’t inherently doomed to fail. With the right approach, it can be a win-win.

Here’s how:

Clarify Your Why
Ask yourself: why are you selling?
- If it’s for the money, negotiate for the highest upfront payment possible.
- If it’s about aligning with a shared vision, choose a buyer whose values match yours.

Focus on Values
Cultural alignment is critical. Deals often fail when values clash. Look no further than the AOL-Time Warner debacle, where misaligned priorities turned a $350 billion merger into a cautionary tale.

Surround Yourself with Experts
Bring in a top-tier investment banker to maximize valuation, an experienced M&A lawyer to protect your interests, and mentors or entrepreneurs who’ve walked this path before to guide you.

Scaling Through M&A

But what if you didn’t sell? What if you flipped the script and used M&A as a tool for growth?

Acquisitions can supercharge your business. They let you expand into new markets faster, bring in immediate revenue, and secure valuable expertise.

Take Spotify, for example. By acquiring Gimlet and Anchor, they became a dominant force in podcasting almost overnight.

If you’re acquiring, success comes down to three key principles:

Align Interests: Keep acquired founders motivated by offering autonomy and equity.
Communicate Relentlessly: Integrate teams thoughtfully, involving them in decisions that affect their future.
Prioritize Culture: Respect the DNA of the businesses you acquire. Culture eats strategy for breakfast, as the saying goes.

M&A: A Strategic Power Move

M&A isn’t just a financial transaction; it’s a strategic choice. Whether you’re selling or acquiring, success lies in clear goals, shared values, and long-term thinking.

Selling your startup might close one chapter, but it can also open a new one. And maybe, just maybe, that next chapter keeps you in the driver’s seat. 🌍

🎁 To celebrate the end of the year, EDHEC Business School, Génération Do It Yourself, and

BrainInvest

are giving you an exclusive 25% off the L’Étincelle training program! This intensive, certification program is open to all and designed to kickstart your entrepreneurial journey — with some of the best in the business by your side: Michael Benabou (Veepee), Fanny Moizant (Vestiaire Collective), Justine Hutteau (Respire)… To grab this amazing deal, simply use the code “BRAININVEST” — so don’t wait, sign up NOW!

Thanks a bunch for reading this far! Feel free to share this edition (and the previous ones) and enjoy lots of perks: stickers, caps, access to events…

Resources for entrepreneurs

Previous articles you'll love :

Catch you soon!

Thanks for reading BrainInvest! This post is public so feel free to share it.